TeamsPlayersDraftExplainers
Christian McCaffreyJonathan Taylor

Christian McCaffrey vs. Jonathan Taylor

Running backs · 2026 season through week 11

By this season's play, Christian McCaffrey: his PlainScore is 83 to Jonathan Taylor's 74, so he ranks ahead of more of the 44 qualified running backs through week 11. Both are on two of the biggest running back contracts in the NFL. Christian McCaffrey leads in 8 of the 12 stats below that can be compared, Jonathan Taylor in 4.

2026, through week 11Christian McCaffrey
49ers
Jonathan Taylor
Colts
Games911
Carries115188
Rushing yards519760
Yards per carry4.54.0
Rushing touchdowns108
Catches4032
Receiving yards431246
Receiving touchdowns30
Fumbles lost14
Share of team carries44%63%
Share of team targets19%13%
Share of offensive snaps68%75%
Fantasy points a game (PPR)23.715.7
Pay per year$19.0M$22.0M
Signed through20272028

Bold marks the better number. Season stats from nflverse box scores; shares of team targets, carries and snaps from nflverse box scores and snap counts. Contract figures only when a named report confirms them.

PlainScore

Percentile among 44 running backsMcCaffreyTaylor
PlainScore8374
Scrimmage yards a game85 (106)78 (91)
Yards per carry78 (4.5)47 (4.0)
Rush EPA97 (0.10)44 (-0.08)
Long runs14 (0.0)76 (2.7)
Yearly pay96 ($19.0M a year)98 ($22.0M a year)

Each number is a percentile against every qualified running back this season: 90 means better than 90% of them. How PlainScore works

Quick answers

Who is better, Christian McCaffrey or Jonathan Taylor?

By this season's play, Christian McCaffrey: his PlainScore is 83 to Jonathan Taylor's 74, so he ranks ahead of more of the 44 qualified running backs through week 11. This is a read of the season so far, not a forecast.

Who has more rushing yards in 2026?

Christian McCaffrey has 519 rushing yards in 9 games (57.7 a game); Jonathan Taylor has 760 in 11 games (69.1 a game).

Who is the better fantasy option, Christian McCaffrey or Jonathan Taylor?

Christian McCaffrey has averaged 23.7 PPR fantasy points a game this season, Jonathan Taylor 15.7. Christian McCaffrey has had 44% of his team's carries, Jonathan Taylor 63%. On the field: 68% of snaps for McCaffrey, 75% for Taylor. Fantasy points use nflverse PPR scoring.

Who gets paid more, Christian McCaffrey or Jonathan Taylor?

Jonathan Taylor averages $22.0M a year (a named report), Christian McCaffrey $19.0M (a named report).

Compare them in the PlainStats appChristian McCaffreyJonathan Taylor

More comparisons

Keep exploring

The Cap Sheet

One short email a week: the contract moves that mattered and one chart. Free.