TeamsPlayersDraftExplainers
J.J. McCarthy

J.J. McCarthy vs. Michael Penix Jr.

Quarterbacks · 2026 season through week 11

Only Michael Penix Jr. has played enough this season for a PlainScore (31 out of 100). J.J. McCarthy has not qualified yet, so compare the season numbers below. Both were first-round quarterbacks in the 2024 draft. J.J. McCarthy leads in 4 of the 9 stats below that can be compared, Michael Penix Jr. in 5.

2026, through week 11J.J. McCarthy
Giants
Michael Penix Jr.
Falcons
Games58
Completion rate63%61%
Passing yards9151,730
Passing yards a game183.0216.2
Yards per attempt8.87.1
Passing touchdowns210
Interceptions27
Sacks taken1012
Rushing yards8594
Rushing touchdowns00
Fantasy points a game (PPR)10.213.6
Pay per year$5.6M$6.1M
Signed through20272027

Bold marks the better number. Season stats from nflverse box scores; shares of team targets, carries and snaps from nflverse box scores and snap counts. Contract figures only when a named report confirms them.

Quick answers

Who is better, J.J. McCarthy or Michael Penix Jr.?

Only Michael Penix Jr. has played enough this season for a PlainScore (31 out of 100). J.J. McCarthy has not qualified yet, so compare the season numbers below. This is a read of the season so far, not a forecast.

Who has more passing yards in 2026?

J.J. McCarthy has 915 passing yards in 5 games (183.0 a game); Michael Penix Jr. has 1,730 in 8 games (216.2 a game).

Who is the better fantasy option, J.J. McCarthy or Michael Penix Jr.?

J.J. McCarthy has averaged 10.2 PPR fantasy points a game this season, Michael Penix Jr. 13.6. Fantasy points use nflverse PPR scoring.

Who gets paid more, J.J. McCarthy or Michael Penix Jr.?

Michael Penix Jr. averages $6.1M a year (calculated from the CBA rookie scale), J.J. McCarthy $5.6M (calculated from the CBA rookie scale).

Compare them in the PlainStats appJ.J. McCarthyMichael Penix Jr.

More comparisons

Keep exploring

The Cap Sheet

One short email a week: the contract moves that mattered and one chart. Free.