
J.J. McCarthy vs. Michael Penix Jr.
Quarterbacks · 2026 season through week 11
Only Michael Penix Jr. has played enough this season for a PlainScore (31 out of 100). J.J. McCarthy has not qualified yet, so compare the season numbers below. Both were first-round quarterbacks in the 2024 draft. J.J. McCarthy leads in 4 of the 9 stats below that can be compared, Michael Penix Jr. in 5.
| 2026, through week 11 | J.J. McCarthy Giants | Michael Penix Jr. Falcons |
|---|---|---|
| Games | 5 | 8 |
| Completion rate | 63% | 61% |
| Passing yards | 915 | 1,730 |
| Passing yards a game | 183.0 | 216.2 |
| Yards per attempt | 8.8 | 7.1 |
| Passing touchdowns | 2 | 10 |
| Interceptions | 2 | 7 |
| Sacks taken | 10 | 12 |
| Rushing yards | 85 | 94 |
| Rushing touchdowns | 0 | 0 |
| Fantasy points a game (PPR) | 10.2 | 13.6 |
| Pay per year | $5.6M | $6.1M |
| Signed through | 2027 | 2027 |
Bold marks the better number. Season stats from nflverse box scores; shares of team targets, carries and snaps from nflverse box scores and snap counts. Contract figures only when a named report confirms them.
Quick answers
Who is better, J.J. McCarthy or Michael Penix Jr.?
Only Michael Penix Jr. has played enough this season for a PlainScore (31 out of 100). J.J. McCarthy has not qualified yet, so compare the season numbers below. This is a read of the season so far, not a forecast.
Who has more passing yards in 2026?
J.J. McCarthy has 915 passing yards in 5 games (183.0 a game); Michael Penix Jr. has 1,730 in 8 games (216.2 a game).
Who is the better fantasy option, J.J. McCarthy or Michael Penix Jr.?
J.J. McCarthy has averaged 10.2 PPR fantasy points a game this season, Michael Penix Jr. 13.6. Fantasy points use nflverse PPR scoring.
Who gets paid more, J.J. McCarthy or Michael Penix Jr.?
Michael Penix Jr. averages $6.1M a year (calculated from the CBA rookie scale), J.J. McCarthy $5.6M (calculated from the CBA rookie scale).
Compare them in the PlainStats appJ.J. McCarthyMichael Penix Jr.
More comparisons
- J.J. McCarthy vs. Jameis Winston
- J.J. McCarthy vs. Bo Nix
- J.J. McCarthy vs. Drake Maye
- J.J. McCarthy vs. Jayden Daniels
- J.J. McCarthy vs. Caleb Williams
- Michael Penix Jr. vs. Bo Nix
- Michael Penix Jr. vs. Drake Maye
- Michael Penix Jr. vs. Jayden Daniels
Keep exploring
- Compare any playersPick two to four players and see them side by side
- Weekly usage risersWhose share of the targets, carries and snaps jumped this week
- Season statsEvery 2026 stat leader, filter by team or position
- Player ratingsHow quarterbacks rank on the field this season
The Cap Sheet
One short email a week: the contract moves that mattered and one chart. Free.